Weekly recap of Coles County home sales during week ending July 19

Coles County Clerk And Recorder Julie Coe (2023) | Coles County Illinois

By East Central Reporter Reports

Jul 26, 2025

There were 13 reported residential sales in Coles County in the week ending July 19, according to BlockShopper.com. The median sales price was $98,000 and the median property tax bill was $1,436 for the previous year. Property taxes based upon most recent assessment in 2022-23.

1216 Southlawn Drive
Mattoon
$98,000
Property Tax: $1,436.28
Effective Property Tax Rate: 1.47%
Buyer: Julie Willingham
Seller: Bradley Sullivan

1015 Tanglewood Drive
Charleston
$257,500
Property Tax: $4,385.6
Effective Property Tax Rate: 1.7%
Buyer: Lisa Walk
Seller: Michael and Stephanie Lynn Nichols

1220 Dewitt
Mattoon
$149,000
Property Tax: $2,093.36
Effective Property Tax Rate: 1.4%
Buyer: Jake R. McBride
Seller: Eric Wright

916 16th St.
Mattoon
$107,500
Property Tax: $1,568.3
Effective Property Tax Rate: 1.46%
Buyer: Charles L. and Bonnie L. Fraser Fish
Seller: Walter L. and Lucille F. McKenzie

2004 Hayes Ave.
Charleston
$96,000
Property Tax: $892.84
Effective Property Tax Rate: 0.93%
Buyer: Elite Estate Flips LLC
Seller: Mark and Mariana Rice

23 Circle Drive
Charleston
$45,000
Property Tax: $3,067.88
Effective Property Tax Rate: 6.82%
Buyer: Nancy G. and Jade Fitzgerald Pinkston
Seller: P and N Properties Inc.

1407 St.
Charleston
$12,000
Property Tax: $1,057.02
Effective Property Tax Rate: 8.81%
Buyer: Mary L. Gienko
Seller: Douglas S. Simpson Simpson Robert G. &

1413 St.
Charleston
$101,000
Property Tax: $972.76
Effective Property Tax Rate: 0.96%
Buyer: Nicholas J. Wagner
Seller: Sara Schmidt

621 Piatt Ave.
Mattoon
$77,000
Property Tax: $635.02
Effective Property Tax Rate: 0.82%
Buyer: Basil R. Beadles
Seller: Swearingen Rentals LLC

15 Fairfield Lane
Charleston
$260,000
Property Tax: $4,364
Effective Property Tax Rate: 1.68%
Buyer: Timothy T. and Alexis K. Spidle
Seller: Theresa M. Gill

613 Seventh St.
Mattoon
$79,000
Property Tax: $320.28
Effective Property Tax Rate: 0.41%
Buyer: Stephanie and Nicholas Sanders
Seller: First Mid Wealth Management Co. Ttee

420 33rd St.
Mattoon
$125,000
Property Tax: $941.92
Effective Property Tax Rate: 0.75%
Buyer: Domenic Zaverella
Seller: Holly R. Pantle

4899 Lake Road
Wabash Point
$46,500
Property Tax: $3,403.52
Effective Property Tax Rate: 7.32%
Buyer: Brian L. Hoenes
Seller: Carrington Mortgage Services LLC