There were 11 reported residential sales in Coles County in the week ending Nov. 22, 2025, according to BlockShopper.com. The median sales price was $120,000 and the median property tax bill was $1,691 for the previous year. Property taxes based upon most recent assessment in 2022-23.
1409 Southlawn Drive
Mattoon
$32,000
Property Tax: $809.32
Effective Property Tax Rate: 2.53%
Buyer: Kurtis W. and Tracie Rankin
Seller: Jennifer Monroe-Craig
617 Sixth St.
Mattoon
$176,000
Property Tax: $2,749.8
Effective Property Tax Rate: 1.56%
Buyer: Jamie Ann Willis
Seller: Michael Lindemann
3012 Richmond Ave.
Mattoon
$120,000
Property Tax: $2,366.94
Effective Property Tax Rate: 1.97%
Buyer: KLB Properties LLC
Seller: Susan Hutchinson
900 14th St.
Mattoon
$84,000
Property Tax: $1,124.12
Effective Property Tax Rate: 1.34%
Buyer: Patricia J. Malloch
Seller: Donald G. Munro III
817 11th St.
Mattoon
$38,000
Property Tax: $1,691.34
Effective Property Tax Rate: 4.45%
Buyer: Shelly and Michael D. Lewis Griffin II
Seller: Everest Commercial Invest LLC
2162 Hidden Lake Court
Charleston
$248,700
Property Tax: $4,740.16
Effective Property Tax Rate: 1.91%
Buyer: Nicholas A. and Danielle Pitts
Seller: Howard Allen Davis
9 Brosam Drive
Charleston
$135,000
Property Tax: $1,269.26
Effective Property Tax Rate: 0.94%
Buyer: Norma G. Smith Beil
Seller: Nicholas Pitts
1404 Sixth St.
Mattoon
$85,000
Property Tax: $1,583.78
Effective Property Tax Rate: 1.86%
Buyer: Rockin E Reality LLC
Seller: Joseph L. and Lorie L. Frantz
908 Buchanan Ave., Unit A
Charleston
$810,000
Property Tax: $1,320.8
Effective Property Tax Rate: 0.16%
Buyer: Buchanan 25 LLC
Seller: Thomas Flanagan
3000 Western Ave.
Mattoon
$182,000
Property Tax: $3,827.44
Effective Property Tax Rate: 2.1%
Buyer: Nicholas J. Delrossi III
Seller: John Armstrong
3220 Richmond Ave.
Mattoon
$28,950
Property Tax: $1,865.26
Effective Property Tax Rate: 6.44%
Buyer: Washington Savings Bank TR #2525
Seller: Louis F. and Betty J. Mayer Jr.
